Home What is Adult ADD? Does ADD Exist? ADD Questionnaire How I Treat ADD Questions / Answers Psych/Neuro Tests Adderall vs Ritalin Vyvanse Non-Med Treatments "High" Dose Stimulants Coaching Gems Research on ADD Reminder System ADD and Psychotherapy Getting Help Ask Dr. Schwartz NY City ADD Specialist Marc Schwartz, MD Guide for Clinicians


The Role of Psychological Testing and Brain Imaging in

Evaluating and Treating ADHD

A set of guidelines for evaluating and monitoring patients with ADD was published in early 2007 by the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.  The guidelines are based on a review by a committee of experts of more than 5,000 papers published since 1996. 

The guidelines state that the diagnosis of ADD should be based on a clinical assessment of the patient.  Expensive neurological or psychological tests add little or no information to what the clinician can learn from interviewing the patient, reviewing the patient's reported symptoms,  and exploring the social, medical, and family history.  In uncommon circumstances during the evaluation process, diagnostic questions may arise about a neurological or psychological condition that may require neuropsychological testing.  Tests should also be performed if the patient appears to have low general cognitive ability or low achievement in language or mathematics despite having a normal intellectual ability. 

In addition, the guidelines state that there is no scientific justification for electronic or radiological imaging of the brain (CT scans, Pet scans, EEG, etc) for the purpose of establishing a diagnosis of ADHD/ADD. 

Students and others who request special accommodations for their ADD are often asked by school or employer disability specialists to take costly tests to certify their diagnosis of ADD.  Such tests may give the diagnosis an appearance of science and certainty but in fact, they provide very little or no diagnostic information beyond that obtained by a good history and clinical examination.

The seven major recommendations of the Academy's report are as follows:

  1. Screening for ADHD should be part of every patient’s mental health assessment (since it is so common among those who seek mental health assistance).
  2. Evaluation of the preschooler, child, or adolescent for ADHD should consist of clinical interviews with the parent and patient, obtaining information about the patient’s school or day-care functioning, evaluation for comorbid (co-existing) psychiatric disorders, and review of the patient’s medical, social, and family history.
  3. If the patient’s medical history is unremarkable, laboratory or neurological testing is not indicated.
  4. Psychological and neuropsychological tests are not mandatory for the diagnosis for ADHD, but should be performed if the patient’s history suggests low general cognitive ability or low achievement in language or mathematics relative to the patient’s intellectual ability.
  5. The clinician must evaluate the patient with ADHD for the presence of comorbid psychiatric disorders.
  6. A well thought-out and comprehensive treatment plan should be developed for the patient with ADHD.
  7. The initial psychopharmacological treatment of ADHD should be a trial with an agent approved by the US Food and Drug Administration for the treatment of ADHD

Details of the guidelines are presented on the web site of the Academy starting on page 6.   


Home What is Adult ADD? Does ADD Exist? ADD Questionnaire How I Treat ADD Questions / Answers Psych/Neuro Tests Adderall vs Ritalin Vyvanse Non-Med Treatments "High" Dose Stimulants Coaching Gems Research on ADD Reminder System ADD and Psychotherapy Getting Help Ask Dr. Schwartz NY City ADD Specialist Marc Schwartz, MD Guide for Clinicians